Research – How much is needed?
Posted by Vana Roth on June 15, 2008
It’s always amused me when I read a book review that states, “The author obviously didn’t research the material”, particularly when it pertains to fiction.
I suppose it’s because I’m new to the writing world and it hasn’t been explained to me yet. I can understand the comment if ones referring to non-fiction. It’s good to know what particles make up an atom if you’re going to write about it, but other than knowing the number of 9mm shells held in the clip of semi-automatic Glock, how much research really needs to be done for fiction?
By definition of fiction, the story’s made up. It’s an embellishment or exaggeration of what could or couldn’t be real. Other than some technical aspects, how much research is truly needed if the story is written well and still convincing? My favorite novels are ones that make me look things up to find out if what’s written is real.
The other day I got a compliment from a reader who actually tracked me down to find out how much of my book ‘A Nation of Expendables’ was fact and how much was fiction. The reader said it was a fantastic read. He also said it scared the heck out of him since the book’s about the risks of identity theft due to unsecured personal information and the extermination those deemed non-productive members of society.
So, I guess you could say my mission was accomplished!
This entry was posted on June 15, 2008 at 1:53 am and is filed under Thoughts, Writing. Tagged: A Nation of Expendables, author, fiction, Lachesis Publishing, research, thriller, Vana Roth, Writing. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Trevas Walker said
I’m always up for a good read. I will have to buy your book.
It makes you feel great when you get feedback like that on your writing (for me anyway).
Vana Roth said
Thanks for your comments Trevas. Since this was my first novel, I really wasn’t sure what to expect. So far those who’ve read the book have spoken favorably which has been a wonderful surprise.
I looked at both your sites and wish you much success!
Dr. Tom Bibey said
Yeah, the notion of research on fiction reminds me of an old bluegrass question.
“Is that a real song or did you make that up?”
I don’t know where to start to answer that.
Dr. Tom Bibey
drtombibey.wordpress.com
Vana Roth said
Hi Dr. Bibey,
You know what they say “There’s a bit of truth in all fiction”. My guess it’s the same for song writing. Either can start from a spark of reality, but where it goes from there is up to the writer.
Thanks for visiting my blog!
krissnp said
more research spoils a plot.
Vana Roth said
Hi Krissnp,
I think you’re right. Depending on the type of book, if there’s too much detail the actual story can get bogged down and lost.
Thanks for commenting.
drtombibey said
Another one I like: “For it to be good fiction, it need not necessarily have happened, but it must be true.”
Dr. Tom Bibey
Vana Roth said
That is a good one Dr. Bibey!
So, using Merriam-Webster’s definition of true, I can say honestly say my book is steadfast and consistent…lol!